Baseballidays

Los Angeles, California

5.7k
 Sales

4.9 (1k)

10 years
on Etsy

4.9 (1k)

5.7k
 sales

10 years
on Etsy

Contact

Following Follow

5.7k
 Sales

4.9 (1k)

10 years
on Etsy

4.9 (1k)

5.7k
 sales

10 years
on Etsy

All 18
Baseballidays ! 1

Contact shop owner

5681 Sales

652 Admirers

Report this shop to Etsy

You reported this shop

Etsy automatically translates most text on the site to your preferred language.

See in original language

Announcement

Last updated on Feb 13, 2026

Customized Key Chains, hand made from professional baseballs, are our # 1 gift item for Senior Day and Coaches gifts. Gift boxes are free for the asking. We pride ourselves on quick turn arounds, no matter the size of the order. If you don't see what you are looking for, message us. We can only list a small amount of what we can customize for your baseball loving fan! Order something that is 1/1 instead of 1/1,000,0000.

Contact shop owner

gregg garfinkel

Reviews

4.9 (1033)

Average item review

We calculate this number using a recency-weighted average of all ratings, with a rating's value decreasing by half each year to best reflect the current experience.

Jason on Oct 15, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Nice little key chain gift

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs
Martha on Oct 14, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Got here FAST! Just what we ordered, in plenty of time for Christmas! Will shop these guys again for sure. We’re a family who loves baseball!

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs
Jill on Oct 14, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

There was an issue with my order but the seller made it right and did so quickly! GREAT customer service and a happy customer and gift recipient.

gregg responded on Oct 14, 2026

So glad we could make it right for you! Come back again!

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs
Kilee on Oct 8, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

I reached out to the seller with some questions and received almost immediate response/feedback. Items arrived quickly after placing an order and are amazing authentic quality.

gregg responded on Oct 13, 2026

You were a pleasure to work with. Thank you.

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs
Phoebe on Oct 6, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Great gift for my baseball loving fiancé!!

gregg responded on Oct 13, 2026

So glad he loved it.

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs
Janelle on Oct 2, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Product is great & as advertised.

gregg responded on Oct 5, 2026

Thanks so much, Janelle. We really appreciate your business.

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs
Patricia on Sep 21, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Very cool - had son-in-laws initials put on the back.

gregg responded on Sep 22, 2026

Thank you so much. Please come back again!

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs
Etsy buyer on Sep 16, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Awesome Product, Fast shipping, Great Seller, I highly recommend.

gregg responded on Sep 18, 2026

Thanks so much! Come back anytime!

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs
Etsy buyer on Sep 16, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

These key chains are just fabulous! I recently completed going to all 30 ballparks! I found charms for the all the teams and wanted something to put them on and hook it to my tote. He added an extra hole at the other end for the extra hook to my bag and made it exactly how I had imagined it⚾️🏟️ He stamped 30 on it too! And added an extra key chain as a nice gift😊 He was prompt addressing by modifications and they came very fast. Faster than this review🙄 we’ve been traveling. I’ll add pictures after I get the charms on! Thank you so much and please if you are considering purchasing one, do it!! And go out and make some memories with it!

gregg responded on Sep 18, 2026

Thanks so much. Please post a photo of the keychain "in the wild."

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs
Zach on Sep 4, 2026

5 out of 5 stars

Gregg was very helpful getting this to us in time for my son’s 16th birthday. He loves it

gregg responded on Sep 8, 2026

My absolute pleasure. So glad it made it in time.

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs

Personalized Hand Made Baseball Key Chain - Made from Professional Baseballs

About Baseballidays

Unique handmade baseball gifts for the baseball fanatic

Sales 5,681

On Etsy since 2016

Unique handmade baseball gifts for the baseball fanatic

Shop members

BASEBALLIDAYS

Owner

I am a baseball fanatic, having played some version of the sport for over 50 years. When my baseball playing sons went away to college, I started this craft. I absolutely love this creative outlet.